SPRRL In-Class Quick Peer Review Form (One Page)
Use this form during live partner review. Keep feedback specific, observable, and actionable.
Use this link to get to the raw Markdown text for this file
How to Use This Form
This page is meant to be copied, not filled in on the website. Open the raw Markdown (or the GitHub view and use the copy button), copy everything below the line, and paste it into a text editor or your notes. Fill it in while you review.
When you finish, email the completed form to your teammate and CC the instructor. Email works no matter where a repository is hosted (GitHub, GitLab, or elsewhere) and whether or not issues are enabled. Paste the text directly into the body of the email so it can be read without opening an attachment. (maybe ask your instructor why Learning Markdown is so useful)
Session Info
- Reviewer:
- Project teammate reviewed:
- Repository:
- Commit/tag reviewed:
- Date:
- Pass:
- Pass 1 (I review teammate)
- Pass 2 (Teammate reviews me)
Quick Evidence Log
- Setup command(s) run:
- Smoke test command(s) run:
- Core result command(s) run:
- Evidence captured:
- Terminal output
- Screenshot(s)
- Notes only
SPRRL Rapid Checks (Pass / Partial / Fail)
Mark one per row.
| Category | Pass | Partial | Fail | One-sentence evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Safe | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | |
| Portable | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | |
| Reproducible | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | |
| Robust | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] | |
| Literate | [ ] | [ ] | [ ] |
Protected-Data Check
- Project uses only shareable data for this review.
- If restricted data exists, teammate provided synthetic/example/mock workflow.
- No sensitive data, credentials, or private keys observed.
Reproducibility Outcome
- PASS: Key result reproduced as expected (or within documented tolerance).
- PARTIAL: Most steps worked; key step blocked/ambiguous.
- FAIL: Could not run enough workflow to evaluate a key result.
Blocking step (if PARTIAL or FAIL):
Feedback to Teammate
Two strengths
1. 2.
Two highest-priority fixes
- Issue -> Impact -> Concrete fix:
- Issue -> Impact -> Concrete fix:
Time Box (for calibration)
- Pre-flight:
- Setup/install:
- Smoke test:
- Core result reproduction:
- Feedback discussion:
- Total:
Two-Pass Completion
- Pass 1 complete and discussed.
- Pass 2 complete and discussed.
- Action items recorded by both teammates.
Next action before submission: